|
On the 26th of June Kieron Brady spoke in Hamilton as part of an Anti Irish Racism parade organised by Cairde Na hEireann. The following is a transcript of that speech.
Can I first of all say that I am humbled to have been asked to speak today at this event to highlight the historic yet still ongoing problem of anti-Irish racism in Scotland. Although not generally a proponent of parades I fully understand and appreciate the necessity for such public demonstration given the lack of preparedness from civic authorities, public services and sporting organisations to comprehensively address the racism and inequalities that impact upon the Irish community, Scotland's biggest ethnic and immigrant community.
Taking to the streets to specify a form of racism is something of a rarity in contemporary society but when we consider the depths of this racism it is imperative that all avenues are pursued which will help in facilitating a more equitable existence for the Irish community, not only in recognising that our community can and does suffer from racism but also to illustrate that we have the fundamental, moral and for many of us, the legal right to see ourselves as Irish. The struggle the Irish in Scotland have faced and continues to face is couched in rhetoric and belief that our cultural upbringing, which shapes for many their national identity is in some way different from those within other immigrant communities. The hostility that exists stems from the centuries old promotion that the Irish are somehow children of a lesser God and that mantra has been the subtext to both the racism that the Irish have had visited upon them both as an immigrant community but also on the island of Ireland itself.
As the consciously intolerant and culturally ignorant persist in undermining our identity all they succeed in doing is portraying why events such as today are necessary. From the elements in the media who have propagated their hostility towards Irish footballers such as Aiden McGeady and James McCarthy, to the racist ensemble who have directed the Famine Song at those who are Scottish born but who are proud of their cultural and ancestral identity, to the fig leaf of the Show Racism the Card organisation who have shown little interest in what the aforementioned players have had to endure, both of whom have had careers in Scotland characterized by ubiquitous racist abuse and the muted response of this particular anti-racist body, conveys the message that somehow the Irish in Scotland are not to be afforded the same recognition as other immigrant communities. It is also vitally important to point out that we do not hope for or seek any preferential treatment, we are fully aware that our friends and neighbours who are of Indian extraction, Pakistani extraction or who are from African and Caribbean backgrounds and identities, and indeed others, have to contend with racist abuse and through visual identification are far more susceptible to racist attacks than the Irish are.
It is facile to merely look at anti-Irish racism and deduce that the problem can be exclusively sourced to those who persistently air such racist abuse through such extreme invective. This is folly and only serves to exculpate those in empowered positions and platforms of influence. It is imperative to continuously focus on all areas where there is a lack of equity for the Irish community and not be drawn into and simply absorbing that such vitriol is exclusive to those who are enveloped with a profound hostility and hatred of all things Irish. Both parties, whether the culturally ignorant or consciously intolerant are persistent in their attempts to demonize and sectariansie our culture and certain commentators in recent times have opined that any overt display of Irishness can justifiably have antipathy and contempt as a recourse. They disregard and are dismissive of some of the fundamental principles of Equality, the right to celebrate identity and the right not to be discriminated against as a consequence of identity.
Last year In England, the Cricket 20/20 World Cup took place. Unlike it's footballing counterpart, taking place in South Africa presently, many of the competing nations supporters had not travelled overseas to watch the extravaganza. In essence there were cricket lovers who were born in Leeds, Manchester, Birmingham, London and a host of other towns and cities in England, as well as I am sure from Glasgow, Edinburgh and elsewhere in Scotland. They turned up to support the land of their fathers, mothers and forebears, including India, Pakistan, Sri Lanka and the West Indies, all this despite the fact that the land of their birth were hosting and competing in one of the games most prestigious tournaments. These fans added colour and camaraderie to the spectacle. Consequently the tournament was viewed as an overwhelming success which was reinforced by the coverage in the sporting press.
Yet in Scotland there is a contrasting view which emanates from many, including sections of the press around the issue of Irishness and those born in Scotland who are of Irish extraction and especially those who are overt about that Irishness. Raymond Travers writing in the Scotland on Sunday opined that 'there is a section of the Celtic support in particular who turn my stomach with their allegiance to the Republic of Ireland in preference to the nation of their birth'. John McKie, writing in the Daily Record in asserted that 'the fact that Glasgow sports shops sell as many Ireland tops as Scottish tops is both pathetic and ultimately unhelpful' whilst Jim Traynor, again in the Daily Record comments that he offers 'no apologies for being a proud Scot and this fixation with Ireland that so many Scots have makes by blood boil'
Many a commentator and columnist within the press actually believe in their musings that they are crusaders against the social cancers of racism, sectarianism, religious intolerance etc. Trust me, they are nothing of the sort. Their views are symptomatic of the anomalies and abnormalities that exist regarding the Irish in Scotland. Such opprobrium does not exist towards the Irish in England, or elsewhere. The racist invective that did exist in such a large scale has been eroded to the point of it being negligible, certainly when we consider it's more critical manifestations.
Anti-Irish racism can be defined as any attack on any facet of Irishness, if the motivation is owing to Irishness, in full or in part, whether that is at a cultural or personal level, it can be the constant contempt of someone's cultural identity or national identity. This is as pertinent whether the victim was born in Coatbridge or Croy, Cork or Cullyhanna. The racism in Britain that impacts upon those of Pakistani, Indian or African extraction is generally directed at those who were born in some part of England, Scotland or Wales, yet there is no ambiguity or reservations in deeming it as racism. Whilst the reality is that many immigrant communities have to contend with and endure racist attitudes there is a constant attempt to undermine the cultural identity of the Irish who were born in Scotland. Broadly speaking, and again to give an example, those of Indian extraction born in Scotland are not vilified for wearing clothing, jewellery etc that is a reflection of where their forebears came from and this does not engender comments that they are Imitation Indians or encourage commentators to adamantly state that 'They are Scottish' and they should at once discard such adornments and attire.
In August 2008 the same Indian community paraded through the street of Scotland to celebrate the 60th Anniversary of Indian independence, they flew the Indian flag and no doubt played songs that pertain to the struggle of liberation. This commemoration was covered in a very positive light on the Scotland Today bulletin later that evening. I doubt anyone would contend that the Irish Community and the celebrations they have regarding the Easter Rising and War of Independence would be afforded such a positive portrayal. This again illustrates the inequalities that the Irish in Scotland endure.
The proudest moment of my brief career in professional football was when I played for Ireland and I was permitted to carry our national flag into the national stadium in Tel Aviv. The fact that me saying this would not prove contentious anywhere, yet in this environment would seem provocative, is indicative of the fact that in this issue it is not my pride that is the source of the problem, it is the ingrained prejudice of those whose attitudes are not replicated elsewhere where the Irish diaspora have settled and made home.
If modern Scotland wants to adhere to the promotion of 'One Scotland Many Cultures' and that we are all 'Jock Tamson's bairns' then it has to accommodate those that see Roisin Dubh as their mother.
Go raibh maith agat
Kieron Brady
Celebrate Identity Challenge Intolerance
www.cici.org.uk
Can I first of all say that I am humbled to have been asked to speak today at this event to highlight the historic yet still ongoing problem of anti-Irish racism in Scotland. Although not generally a proponent of parades I fully understand and appreciate the necessity for such public demonstration given the lack of preparedness from civic authorities, public services and sporting organisations to comprehensively address the racism and inequalities that impact upon the Irish community, Scotland's biggest ethnic and immigrant community.
Taking to the streets to specify a form of racism is something of a rarity in contemporary society but when we consider the depths of this racism it is imperative that all avenues are pursued which will help in facilitating a more equitable existence for the Irish community, not only in recognising that our community can and does suffer from racism but also to illustrate that we have the fundamental, moral and for many of us, the legal right to see ourselves as Irish. The struggle the Irish in Scotland have faced and continues to face is couched in rhetoric and belief that our cultural upbringing, which shapes for many their national identity is in some way different from those within other immigrant communities. The hostility that exists stems from the centuries old promotion that the Irish are somehow children of a lesser God and that mantra has been the subtext to both the racism that the Irish have had visited upon them both as an immigrant community but also on the island of Ireland itself.
As the consciously intolerant and culturally ignorant persist in undermining our identity all they succeed in doing is portraying why events such as today are necessary. From the elements in the media who have propagated their hostility towards Irish footballers such as Aiden McGeady and James McCarthy, to the racist ensemble who have directed the Famine Song at those who are Scottish born but who are proud of their cultural and ancestral identity, to the fig leaf of the Show Racism the Card organisation who have shown little interest in what the aforementioned players have had to endure, both of whom have had careers in Scotland characterized by ubiquitous racist abuse and the muted response of this particular anti-racist body, conveys the message that somehow the Irish in Scotland are not to be afforded the same recognition as other immigrant communities. It is also vitally important to point out that we do not hope for or seek any preferential treatment, we are fully aware that our friends and neighbours who are of Indian extraction, Pakistani extraction or who are from African and Caribbean backgrounds and identities, and indeed others, have to contend with racist abuse and through visual identification are far more susceptible to racist attacks than the Irish are.
It is facile to merely look at anti-Irish racism and deduce that the problem can be exclusively sourced to those who persistently air such racist abuse through such extreme invective. This is folly and only serves to exculpate those in empowered positions and platforms of influence. It is imperative to continuously focus on all areas where there is a lack of equity for the Irish community and not be drawn into and simply absorbing that such vitriol is exclusive to those who are enveloped with a profound hostility and hatred of all things Irish. Both parties, whether the culturally ignorant or consciously intolerant are persistent in their attempts to demonize and sectariansie our culture and certain commentators in recent times have opined that any overt display of Irishness can justifiably have antipathy and contempt as a recourse. They disregard and are dismissive of some of the fundamental principles of Equality, the right to celebrate identity and the right not to be discriminated against as a consequence of identity.
Last year In England, the Cricket 20/20 World Cup took place. Unlike it's footballing counterpart, taking place in South Africa presently, many of the competing nations supporters had not travelled overseas to watch the extravaganza. In essence there were cricket lovers who were born in Leeds, Manchester, Birmingham, London and a host of other towns and cities in England, as well as I am sure from Glasgow, Edinburgh and elsewhere in Scotland. They turned up to support the land of their fathers, mothers and forebears, including India, Pakistan, Sri Lanka and the West Indies, all this despite the fact that the land of their birth were hosting and competing in one of the games most prestigious tournaments. These fans added colour and camaraderie to the spectacle. Consequently the tournament was viewed as an overwhelming success which was reinforced by the coverage in the sporting press.
Yet in Scotland there is a contrasting view which emanates from many, including sections of the press around the issue of Irishness and those born in Scotland who are of Irish extraction and especially those who are overt about that Irishness. Raymond Travers writing in the Scotland on Sunday opined that 'there is a section of the Celtic support in particular who turn my stomach with their allegiance to the Republic of Ireland in preference to the nation of their birth'. John McKie, writing in the Daily Record in asserted that 'the fact that Glasgow sports shops sell as many Ireland tops as Scottish tops is both pathetic and ultimately unhelpful' whilst Jim Traynor, again in the Daily Record comments that he offers 'no apologies for being a proud Scot and this fixation with Ireland that so many Scots have makes by blood boil'
Many a commentator and columnist within the press actually believe in their musings that they are crusaders against the social cancers of racism, sectarianism, religious intolerance etc. Trust me, they are nothing of the sort. Their views are symptomatic of the anomalies and abnormalities that exist regarding the Irish in Scotland. Such opprobrium does not exist towards the Irish in England, or elsewhere. The racist invective that did exist in such a large scale has been eroded to the point of it being negligible, certainly when we consider it's more critical manifestations.
Anti-Irish racism can be defined as any attack on any facet of Irishness, if the motivation is owing to Irishness, in full or in part, whether that is at a cultural or personal level, it can be the constant contempt of someone's cultural identity or national identity. This is as pertinent whether the victim was born in Coatbridge or Croy, Cork or Cullyhanna. The racism in Britain that impacts upon those of Pakistani, Indian or African extraction is generally directed at those who were born in some part of England, Scotland or Wales, yet there is no ambiguity or reservations in deeming it as racism. Whilst the reality is that many immigrant communities have to contend with and endure racist attitudes there is a constant attempt to undermine the cultural identity of the Irish who were born in Scotland. Broadly speaking, and again to give an example, those of Indian extraction born in Scotland are not vilified for wearing clothing, jewellery etc that is a reflection of where their forebears came from and this does not engender comments that they are Imitation Indians or encourage commentators to adamantly state that 'They are Scottish' and they should at once discard such adornments and attire.
In August 2008 the same Indian community paraded through the street of Scotland to celebrate the 60th Anniversary of Indian independence, they flew the Indian flag and no doubt played songs that pertain to the struggle of liberation. This commemoration was covered in a very positive light on the Scotland Today bulletin later that evening. I doubt anyone would contend that the Irish Community and the celebrations they have regarding the Easter Rising and War of Independence would be afforded such a positive portrayal. This again illustrates the inequalities that the Irish in Scotland endure.
The proudest moment of my brief career in professional football was when I played for Ireland and I was permitted to carry our national flag into the national stadium in Tel Aviv. The fact that me saying this would not prove contentious anywhere, yet in this environment would seem provocative, is indicative of the fact that in this issue it is not my pride that is the source of the problem, it is the ingrained prejudice of those whose attitudes are not replicated elsewhere where the Irish diaspora have settled and made home.
If modern Scotland wants to adhere to the promotion of 'One Scotland Many Cultures' and that we are all 'Jock Tamson's bairns' then it has to accommodate those that see Roisin Dubh as their mother.
Go raibh maith agat
Kieron Brady
Celebrate Identity Challenge Intolerance
www.cici.org.uk
|
Comments
Like everyone else i can only draw knowledge and identity from my parents and surrounding neighbourhood; Where i was brought up has always had
a large Irish multi generational community but even then my parents where uneasy about drawing attention or instigating antipathy with overt
displays of Irishness, The first Ireland strip i had i bought myself at 17; it's part of my heritage and cultural identity i'm not gonna disown it because some neanderthal reacts with ridicule( which i must add doesn't happen too often being 6`2 & 17st with 2 brothers of similar stature);they kinda just look through gritted teeth which for me makes it all the sweeter. We have a right to ourselves and our forefathers not to forget where we came from.....
The real tragedy is that if the above mentioned journo's ever read Kieron's piece they would probably scoff and dismiss it as 'paranoia' and unsupported victimization. Dare I say it Leckie would probably dismiss it to his family and fellow lodge members as such "These fenians and they're whinning. If they hate this country so much then why don't they....that's right boys.....everybody join in.....GO HOME, WHY DON'T YOU GO HO......"
Ah but it's just a bit of fun, right Martin Bain???
Wonder how funny it would be if the tables were turned and we started replying in kind with some 'fun' wee ditties about British soldiers dying in Iraq. Nup, not doubt that would be deemed bang out of order as they were 'brave Brits' where as the famine victims were mere 'poor taigs'.
Oh Ian Archer....how I long for thee.
As for contribution No.4, ''when do we stop considering ourselves Irish?'' asks elitejcx. What business is it of yours, mate? We are all entitled to retain or even claim the identity we wish.
You say you don't consider yourself Irish, as if anybody CGAF. Of all the responses this subject invariably elicits, this is the one that amuses me most -- ''I don't consider myself Irish so why should you?'' is what you're really trying to say, isn't it? This is the problem in a nutshell. Scots get agitated about Irish people clinging to their identity but could care less about Indians, Pakistanis, Poles or Italians doing the same.
Kieron Brady, like James Mac Millan before him, articulates the problem beautifully. It's not known as Scotland's Shame for nothing. But I've often found that the second-generation Murphys and McKennas and O'Neills are the most critical, as if, like Traynor and McNee, condemning ethnic Irish people for clinging to Irishness will make them in some way more Scottish.
I've got news for them -- among the blazered bigots in the golf clubs and masonic halls they are just Fenian bastards like the rest of us. Enjoy, saddos! lol!
I don't doubt for a minute anti-Irish racism is prevelent in Scottish society today, it's my personal opinion about my on heritage, it's mostly Irish (7/8 of my Great Grandparents are Irish), but I view myself as Scottish. People I know of Italian extraction view themselves of Scots-Italians or Italian-Scots, I have Jewish friends who celebrate the dual indentity wearing kilts at weddings/Bar Mitzvahs. There seems to be a problem do we view ourselves as Irish-Scots or as just Irish? Scotland's and Ireland's cultures are intwined why do we show so much difference between us then?
the point of one homogenous culture...... I beg to differ, Ireland is seen by many in this country as the
vanquished nation with a culture that has to assimilate to the Scottish way of life. Overt signs of Irishness
from a Scot of Irish extraction is frowned upon; ask your self this would your Italien/Jewish friends
with their dual cultures be looked upon as plastic or fake for celebrating their heritage; if your answer is
no then tell me why i can't celebrate my Irish Heritage without being accused of being a lesser scot.....
Maybe the Overt signs of Irishness reminds some folk of why our forefathers came to this land; The near
annialation of the irish, Scattered to the four corners of the globe all convieniently blamed on the potato or provedancejust depends which Brit you ask.
Do you think maybe 800 years of imperial rule from Britain, hasn't shaped the physche of the Indigenous Scot??
Anyhoo i'm scottish by Birth so therfore SCOTTISH by my lineage and heritage is Irish of which i am very proud and will never disassociate myself from.....
Last word
RSS feed for comments to this post.